A good discussion of the problems with Checked Exceptions is in this article by Brian Goetz. The main problems can be summarized as:
- Unnecessary exposure of implementation details.
- Unstable method signatures.
- Unreadable code.
- Exception swallowing.
- Too much Exception wrapping.
Problems 1 and 2 are caused by poor design. By ensuring that exceptions are thrown at the right level of abstraction, these problems can be avoided. Of course, this means greater effort by the programmer, and also leads to problem 5 - ie - too much exception wrapping.
As for problem 3, I think that any piece of code that has proper error handling will always be less readable than code that has no error handling. This is the reason why so much text book code has very little or no error handling. In a production system, unlike in text books, readability is important, but proper error handling is even more important.
Since so many articles talk about the problems with Checked Exceptions, perhaps a novel approach to this issue is to look at the problems caused by Unchecked Exceptions. These, in my view, can be summarized as:
- Lack of information in method signatures. So that by looking at a method signature, you cannot tell what exceptions are likely to be thrown.
- Java compiler will not warn you if you ignore exceptions. Therefore, rather than thinking about every possible exception, you will be blissfully unaware of potential exceptional conditions. The result is likely to be an unstable system; one that crashes with indecipherable errors.
- Loss of information. Since information about exceptional conditions is fairly local within a system, when an exception at a lower level is caught and wrapped at a higher level, there is potential for additional information to be supplied to diagnose the problem. Since unchecked exceptions pass through silently, all you will get is the cryptic error at the lowest level of abstraction with very little contextual information other than the stack trace.
- Exception swallowing. Let us not forget that the most common method of swallowing Exceptions, ie, catching all Exceptions, will also swallow Unchecked Exceptions. I have seen programmers swallowing Exceptions because they find this an easy and simple way to fix that annoying NullPointerException.
- Whether you like it or not, Java uses Checked Exceptions everywhere in its libraries. Therefore, even if you throw Unchecked Exceptions, chances are that programmers will still swallow Exceptions, because they still need to deal with the Checked Exceptions thrown by Java libraries.
- As it is, programmers do not like to think about error handling. To encourage the use of Unchecked Exceptions is to encourage this behaviour, as there will be even less inclination to think about exceptional conditions.
If you are still not convinced, read this excellent interview with Bruce Lindsay, where he talks about the type of error handling that goes into building a DBMS.